Video: SAP Expert Vinnie Mirchandani Sees No Rush to S/4HANA

David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
4 min read

SAP is in a hurry to get customers to move to its next generation S/4HANA platform. Yet most SAP customers are in no hurry to move — nor should they be, according to SAP watcher Vinnie Mirchandani.

You can hear from Vinnie directly by watching the video clips embedded in this post (or watch them all as a single, seven-minute video). What follows are my notes on what I found most interesting.

Vinnie is the author of two books focused specifically on SAP, SAP Nation and SAP Nation 2.0, and others on broader trends in technology and business, including Silicon Collar and The New Technology Elite. Before founding his own advisory firm, Deal Architect, he was a Gartner analyst. He also spent 14 years as a management consultant for PriceWaterhouse.

He has analyzed SAP from his days at Gartner, and more recently has helped several clients evaluate SAP’s strategy with S/4HANA, a major overhaul of its core technology. Part of SAP’s challenge is compelling customers to migrate away from a technology foundation that is already solid, the Enterprise Core Component (ECC) architecture many SAP customers have spent decades implementing and tuning.

Ready for a Complete Overhaul?

One positive feedback we get from customers all the time is how robust the existing ECC software is,” he says. “The complaint they have is it should be going down in cost.” Rather than continuing to invest large amounts of money in core transactional systems that already work well, business and technology leaders want to aim more of their technology budget at new challenges. S/4 is gradually delivering what ECC supports in accounting, materials management, shop floor and other capabilities. But those process areas have not remained static in the last two decades. To make it attractive, S/4 will have to deliver a significant leap. Also, S/4 is not scheduled to support Industry Extensions any time soon so they will stay in the current client/server architecture, potentially increasing complexity of IT management.

SAP’s strategy these days, as Vinnie told me when I saw him a few weeks ago, can be summed up as, “What’s the question? The answer is HANA.” With S/4, SAP is moving away from decades of commitment to database independence by only offering it on HANA. Besides the additional lock-in it creates, HANA requires investment in new talent and systems management. It also creates more interoperability issues as few non-SAP applications or SAP’s own Industry Extensions will not be on HANA. S/4 also improves the user interface compared to previous SAP products, but with the world moving to digital assistants and natural interfaces it may get you half way there.

At a time when SAP is investing most heavily in HANA rather than its ECC 6 installed base, Vinnie thinks it’s reasonable for those who are in no rush to upgrade to explore ways of lowering their total cost of owning and operating their ERP systems. The analogy he often uses is that getting third party support for your ERP is like buying a high-end sports car but getting your vehicle serviced by a trusted mechanic, rather than paying for overpriced parts and service directly from the dealer.

Massive Migration Costs


Beyond the direct expense of licensing the new software, customers worry about “massive migration costs” associated with moving to HANA, Vinnie says.

He doesn’t necessarily disagree SAP’s core technology was in need of a major refresh. Yet based on the history of the software industry, it’s unlikely S/4HANA will match the breadth, depth, and reliability of ECC 6 and related Industry Solution extensions anytime soon, he says. “I’ve looked at how long Oracle Fusion took to build, I’ve looked at how long Microsoft is trying to rationalize its acquisitions (it had a project called Project Green), JD Edwards when they rolled out OneWorld, and now Infor is trying to roll out their own cloud offerings. They take time to mature, then their customers take decades to migrate.

A Five-to-10-Year Plan

“People ask me about S/4HANA and what do we do? Should we wait? Should we plunge ahead? I tell them wait,” Vinnie says. A brand new SAP customer, especially a smaller one not needing industry specific functionality might be wise to adopt S/4HANA now and avoid the need to migrate later. Even there, he would recommend they consider the multi-tenant, public cloud option.

Meanwhile, the way to innovate as a business is not to adopt a new ERP system. Instead, think in terms of a hybrid IT or postmodern ERP strategy that preserves investments in core transactional systems but supplements it with other software and cloud services, Vinnie says. “You’re innovating around the edges: customer facing, supply chain, shop floor, et cetera. You see that quite often. SAP becomes the transaction processing backbone, but more and more people are saying, away from that core, I’m going to look at much more modern solutions, much more nimble startup solutions. Or I’m going to custom build some of that.”

That does not mean it will never make sense to move to S/4HANA, but Vinnie suggests thinking in terms of a five-to-10-year plan. Take advantage of resources like Rimini Street support to stretch your current investment as long as you possibly can while you wait for S/4HANA to mature.

“You may find — five, seven, 10 years from now — that you don’t want to buy the complete suite from SAP,” Vinnie says. “The world is going to be very different in the next few years. So this buys you the flexibility without having to pay 100 percent of the cost while you wait to see what makes sense to evolve towards.”

David Rowe

Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation

Mr. Rowe serves as Chief Marketing and Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation. In this role, he is responsible for Rimini Street’s global product and marketing strategy and execution. He also leads initiatives to reinvent, transform and scale Rimini Street’s business for billion-dollar revenue operations.

More from David Rowe

On-Premises ERP Innovation: A New Path Forward without the Platform Upheaval
Blog
On-Premises ERP Innovation: A New Path Forward without the Platform Upheaval
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

The enterprise software landscape witnessed a seismic shift with our announcement of the partnership with ServiceNow, made public during their Q3 2024 financial results. Rimini Street and ServiceNow’s collaboration introduced a groundbreaking approach for organizations running on-premises ERP systems to access cutting-edge automation, visibility and AI capabilities without the traditional requirement of a complete migration […]

Rimini Street + ServiceNow
Blog
Rimini Street + ServiceNow
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

Titans of Transformation Partnerships that combine deep expertise with cutting-edge innovation are rare and invaluable. The recently announced collaboration between Rimini Street and ServiceNow represents just such a union – a powerful alliance poised to tackle some of the IT industry’s most formidable challenges. This partnership brings together two companies with parallel 20-year histories of […]

Three Ways CIOs Must Rethink Cloud ROI
Blog
Three Ways CIOs Must Rethink Cloud ROI
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
4 min read

While cloud workloads will continue to grow, savvy tech leaders must take a step back and evaluate the true ROI of moving to the cloud. Here’s three ways to get started. If there’s one habit CIOs should consider adopting, it’s a commitment to take a critical look at their cloud Return On Investment (ROI). Over […]

Delivering More Value by Supporting More Software
Blog
Delivering More Value by Supporting More Software
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
2 min read

Need to focus your limited IT resources on innovation while ensuring your complex software portfolio continues to support mission-critical operations? A new service offering called Rimini Custom™ can help. Here’s how. As an IT leader, your purview is growing more—not less—complex every day. In fact, an eye-opening report from Salesforce indicated that, on average, organizations […]

Feeling the Pressure of Moving ERP to the Cloud? It’s Not as Urgent as Vendors Would Have You Think.
Blog
Feeling the Pressure of Moving ERP to the Cloud? It’s Not as Urgent as Vendors Would Have You Think.
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
4 min read

Implement hybrid IT instead and invest the savings in transformation.   An October 2020 Diginomica article, “Don’t be a sheep – challenge the call to re-platform ERP” from author Brian Sommer, contains some pragmatic advice for CIOs feeling the pressure of moving ERP to the cloud.   It’s not necessary to replace or re-platform important […]

yellow paper airplane
Blog
On-Going IT Response to the Global Pandemic: The View from a Front-Row Seat
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
5 min read

In January’s “2020 State of the CIO Executive Summary,” the news was good for CIOs… They were getting increased recognition from CEOs and colleagues for their growing and essential leadership role in business strategy, innovation, and revenue generation — while decreasing time spent on important yet “back-office” activities such as optimizing the enterprise IT infrastructure […]

How to Join the Digital Vanguard
Blog
How to Join the Digital Vanguard
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

Is your organization a digital laggard or a member of the digital vanguard? I’ve been reading Deloitte’s 2018 CIO Survey, which makes a point of distinguishing between “vanguard” organizations where IT actively contributes to creating new businesses and business opportunities and everyone else. The traditional role of the CIO has been to be an operational […]

Strategies for Supporting SAP S/4HANA From “Wait And See” To “Full Speed Ahead”
Blog
Strategies for Supporting SAP S/4HANA From “Wait And See” To “Full Speed Ahead”
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
5 min read

Clients of Rimini Street’s support for SAP have the freedom to make independent decisions about S/4HANA – but that doesn’t necessarily mean they reject SAP’s reinvention of its ERP software. Some are moving forward with S/4HANA, while continuing to rely on Rimini Street for high quality and cost effective support of their existing SAP Business […]

Biggest Obstacle to Innovation, IT Leaders Say: “Keeping the Lights On”
Blog
Biggest Obstacle to Innovation, IT Leaders Say: “Keeping the Lights On”
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

Businesses want to innovate faster because they know successful innovators tend to be the most successful businesses. Yet if you survey IT and finance leaders, as we did recently in conjunction with Vanson Bourne, a technology market research firm, you will find many are dissatisfied with the pace of innovation happening in their organizations. The […]

Why a Stable, Available Business Platform is Key — Today and Tomorrow
Blog
Why a Stable, Available Business Platform is Key — Today and Tomorrow
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

As the role of IT evolves from keeping the lights on to helping shape business strategy, technology leaders are challenged to find room for those strategic projects in their schedules and in their budgets. In a recent poll by CIO, 72 percent of those surveyed admitted they are struggling to balance business innovation and operational […]

Smart Strategies That Will Boost IT Cost Optimization
Blog
Smart Strategies That Will Boost IT Cost Optimization
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

Digital transformation is picking up speed. It’s driving businesses to rethink their traditional imperatives and bringing a new focus on customer engagement and disruptive business models. As companies emphasize new priorities, they need to optimize inefficient processes and reduce burdensome costs that are a drag on their business. For IT, that requires some tough choices. […]

What You Need to Know About Bimodal IT
Blog
What You Need to Know About Bimodal IT
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

The digital economy is all about fast innovation and getting new products to market more quickly than competitors. IT needs to step up its game to help drive innovation, without sacrificing top priorities such as compliance, cost control and maintaining availability. The stakes are high even for massive, successful businesses. Today, 50 percent of the […]

Overcoming the #1 Barrier to Digital Transformation
Blog
Overcoming the #1 Barrier to Digital Transformation
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
3 min read

For years, IT has had clearly defined responsibilities: Keep critical business systems up and running, control costs and meet security and compliance requirements. Even today, most of your IT budget is likely spent keeping the lights on. But this traditional focus is holding organizations back in an era of accelerating focus on customer experience enabled […]

Three Ways CIOs Can Successfully Support Business Objectives
Blog
Three Ways CIOs Can Successfully Support Business Objectives
David Rowe
David Rowe
Chief Product Officer & EVP, Global Transformation
4 min read

It’s no secret that we’re doing business in a fast-paced, disruptive environment. To keep pace with rapid change, IT is becoming more strategic, and expectations are growing. According to CIO, “boards of directors, CEOs and business colleagues are turning to the CIO to lead digital transformations, win customers and drive revenue.” CIOs are feeling the […]